The Poor

I noticed some discussions around a new study just released that says the proportion of poor, at least as defined by the Federal government, has declined somewhat over the last few years.

Naturally, the Left is invested in the idea that conservative policies make the rich richer and the poor poorer. The Right believes freedom and lower taxes create more opportunities for the poor to pull themselves up to prosperity.

Another interesting trend is among new Christian socialists, who have somehow decided that Jesus was a socialist. Their simplistic idea is that Jesus exhorted his followers to help the poor, so that somehow morphed into the position that Christians today should petition their government to confiscate more money from everyone else and redistribute it to the poor.

Actually, Jesus never told anybody to go to Rome and lobby Ceasar to tax the rich and give the money to the poor. He told individuals to help the poor. One poor rich fellow he challenged to sell everything, give the money to the poor, and follow him. That fellow walked away shaking his head, because that was the only thing in his life he couldn't do for Christ.

No, Jesus wasn't talking about helping the poor by trying to influence the government to confiscate the money from other people. He was talking about each of us caring about others and doing what we can to help those in need.

It's interesting to me that "poor" is in the eye of the beholder. Those in the United States labeled "poor" would be considered to be living high on the hog by the actual poor in third-world countries. Recently there have been studies trying to find people who are homeless and starving, and they struggled to find anyone. Homelessness would seem to be a choice these days rather than a forced condition - government housing programs, shelters, and all sorts of public assistance are accessible for anyone willing to seek them out. Food stamps and community food banks and school lunch programs and churches with free meals abound.

I've seen and met several members of the American poor underclass. They tend to be third or fourth generation poor, living as their parents and grandparents did since the start of Lyndon Johnson's Great Society welfare programs. They tend to be experts at working the system, knowing all of the government aid programs and local charities and taking advantage of them all. Mostly, they would be physically and mentally able to work, but holding a full-time job is the last thing they aspire to do.

The key to receiving housing, healthcare, food stamps, and cash, as most of these folks know, is children. Make sure there are a couple of dependent children in the household and there are agencies and charities all over the place eager to provide assistance and services.

Why work for a living if you can have a home, food, clothing, medical care, and some spending money by just learning to exploit the social services system? These "poor" folks have cable television and often even big-screen televisions. They have cars. For them, it's a better life than having to punch a timeclock every day and struggle to make house payments, car payments, buy insurance, pay for medical care and prescription drugs, etc.

Want a government approach to helping the poor that really works? Take the money out of the system. Transform social services to be there to help, but those who need help must come to them and ask for it. If people need food, it will be given to them. If they need a place to stay, a temporary room will be provided. Mainly, they need a job, so every person accessing services will receive assistance in finding a job.

Social services should exist for the purpose of helping the poor and needy become independent, not keeping them dependent. The approach is common sense, and it cannot fail. But politicians are more interested in buying votes than in solving problems, and Democrat politicians in particular have found a gold mine of votes among the poor. Get them a roof and food and some cash so they don't have to get a job, and they'll vote for you the rest of their life.